The hospital’s electronic medical record recently underwent some major upgrades, new code written and uploaded, allowing administration to inch ever closer to their singular goal of making my head explode once and for all as the computers are clunkier, buggier, and more sluggish than ever.
Anyhoo, the cosmetic changes to the interface include a colored backdrop for patient names, the previous generic white now shaded blue for boys and pink for girls. Although I’d never picked up on this before , the new cotton candy colored screens make it strikingly obvious that the female patients substantially outnumber the males, I’d guess by about 2 to 1.
Why is this I wonder, other than my devastatingly good looks? Women outlive men by a substantial margin, shouldn’t they be healthier than men and therefore have fewer ER visits?
Then again, women’s reproductive parts are fraught with complications. Women get pregnant far more often, it’s rare not to see at least a patient or two per shift with some sort of pregnancy issue whether it be cramping, bleeding, nausea, or acute ultrasound deficiency. The number of women showing up with discharge or painful urination dwarfs their male counterparts. Ovaries are much more prone to painful problems than testicles. Tampons and IUD strings get lost. All in all I’ve learned it’s much riskier being a female. And that I should have been an accountant.
But men have gender specific diseases too, like trauma, they being far more likely to mangle themselves in various creative ways as compared to women. The root of the ER gender disparity then, I submit, is found not in the pelvis, but instead laying north within the gray and white matter between the ears.
Women are far more prone to somatization, the process of anxiety or stress manifesting itself as a physical symptom. Women seem to be wired in such a way that their negative emotions lead directly to chest pains, or abdominal pain, or shortness of breath, or headaches, or diarrhea, or weakness, or dizziness far more often than in men. The discomfort is real, but the root cause is not physiologic but instead psychosomatic.
And then, women are not only more likely to develop symptoms, but they are more likely to do something about them. Men prefer to put their heads in the sand, dealing with disease in the same way they handle the homeless guy asking for spare change at a stoplight: by looking the other way and hoping it moves on. Women are far more proactive, their threshold for seeking medical evaluation significantly lower. It’s never the husband who drags his unwilling macho wife to the ER to be checked out for this or that.
This is all about populations of course and cannot be applied to individuals — there are plenty of guys who show up with anxiety-induced chest pain scared they’re having a heart attack. But taken as a whole, and applied over thousands of patient interactions, these differences between the sexes have over time have become more and more apparent to me. And it’s a factor in what the bulk of emergency medicine is in this country: it’s not about taking care of actual emergencies, it’s about offering reassurance that there isn’t one.
June 22, 2009 at 11:33 am
Great post! I never thought about the fact that women would come in for so many more pregnancy related things.
I do have to argue with you about one thing though… my husband has dragged me into the ER more than once for an injury which I wanted to wait to have seen (or ignore). I agree that I am probably in the minority, though.
June 22, 2009 at 10:12 pm
You’ve really got to feel for those acute ultrasound deficiencies…
June 23, 2009 at 9:59 am
I agree – however, lets see how many women commenters out there get annoyed with your conclusions.
June 23, 2009 at 10:12 am
You did leave out one male “disease” we see commonly in the ER:
The Man-Baby Syndrome (MBS) – whiny male, 25-45 accompanied by his mom or a wife who acts like his mom. There are several gradations of this which have acronyms that are not appropriate for publication.
June 23, 2009 at 4:18 pm
Why is this I wonder, other than my devastatingly good looks?
Correlation between this and women arriving with chest pain, anxiety and heart fluttering in your ER?
June 24, 2009 at 7:34 am
I am also one of those have to be dragged to the doctor or ER type women. a broken elbow wasn’t enough to get me to leave class in the middle of the day. my hubby on the other hand will go to the ER with severe gas pains/stomach cramps because he always freaks out and thinks there’s something seriously wrong, like appendicitis or an intestinal blockage. And he’s always been fine, just needed to poo.
June 24, 2009 at 12:25 pm
Its the worried well that accounts for 80% of our business. Without them would I even have a job?
June 24, 2009 at 12:47 pm
Sorry, the ‘dude’ having a baby is still a woman. I’ve seen plenty of women with facial hair. And women without breasts due to cancer. I know it’s just sensationalistic journalism at play, but it still bugs me. When you can sprout a uterus then you can be a girl, before that you have a psych issue.
June 26, 2009 at 6:45 am
Great post! I had to take my 2 year old to the hospital last week and I was so afraid they were going to think I was a crazy, over-reacting Munchausen’s by Proxy sufferer!
But I have been known to go myself during pregnancy for a very bad upper respiratory infection-I thought that if I was having trouble breathing, so would baby. Then I totally worked myself up into needing to go to the ER. Silliness!
June 26, 2009 at 8:07 am
Heh, my mom would be dead if my dad hadn’t dragged her to the doctor, she’s definitely of the “ignore it and it’ll go away” school (not so effective with melanoma, it turns out).
July 7, 2009 at 9:42 am
Is it bad that I’ve read so many blogs that I can predict typical [annoying] comment responses?
“Bla bla bla, here’s my story you didn’t ask for that contradicts what you just said, HOW DARE YOU MAKE A GENERAL OBSERVATION!?!?!”
“How dare you…are you saying women are weak? whiny? psychosomatic seekers!?! WHERE’S YOUR COMPASSION!?!??”
Luckily there are more good/humorous/normal posts that make up the majority
Um, yeah, good post though
ha.
July 15, 2009 at 12:06 am
Duh. We live longer because we go to the doctoer when we can’t breath/have chest pain/have blood pumping out of a wound. That, my friend, is why women live longer.
September 10, 2009 at 1:52 pm
Venus and Mars is true in outpatient surgery (Where I work) as well. The majority of our patients are female, the male patient on some days becoming an oddity. (O it’s a man,let me have him!) So much of GYN is outpatient now: essure, ablation, ligation, slings. We should just paint the walls pink. “Nothing in your vagina for 4 weeks ” is a phrase repeated so often I some times mistakenly say it to our few male patients! “Wait, didn’t I have my hernia repaired?’ “Oh, yeah, I meant no sex for 4 weeks”
September 13, 2009 at 1:03 pm
There’s also a social dynamic at work. Speaking, as you say, about populations, individuals vary, etc etc…. Women by and large are the caregivers. When men have difficulties they often get some measure of sympathy. Men are rather famous for not noticing women’s states of mind. The result is that if women want to have their troubles noticed, they better be medical. That way it’s not their “fault,” it’s harder to tell them to suck it up, and it’s “real.”
Sad thing is, often it becomes real. Minds are too powerful for their own good.
October 29, 2009 at 3:06 pm
Really nice thought!
“……it’s not about taking care of actual emergencies, it’s about offering reassurance that there isn’t one.”
November 14, 2009 at 11:51 pm
What about Intersexed people? Purple? Or do they get assigned the sex they most closely resemble?
e.g. In 1985 I was diagnosed as an Intersexed male. In 2005, after a lot of tests (caused by some really interesting somatic changes), that was changed to Intersexed female.
Yes, I know, we’re rare, but such medical data record entry restrictions can actually kill us.